When it comes to parties, not every one has to be super fancy! I know caviar has it’s place, but my go to is always the comfort food. This easy comfort food party platter is quick, nostalgic and a total crowd pleaser. In true Lauren (me) fashion, it’s some prep, some work, but mostly just the easy way of putting together some party food. You can check out the DIY video and written walk through below!
Disclosure: I have affiliate links in this post. That means when you click on a link, if you buy something, I get a commission. This does not cost you any extra money. They are just bouncing back a commission to me for sending you their way! And, don’t worry, I won’t recommend anything from a website I don’t trust. I have your back! Plus I shop all these places too! Want more info? Check out the EventOTB Privacy Policy
What You Need for Your Comfort Food Party Platter
- Small pre-sliced bread (or you can get a baguette and slice yourself). I used pre-sliced Ciabatta from the grocery store
- Butter
- Parmesean Cheese (I used shaved, but shredded works too)
- Gouda & Cheddar cheese slices (or whatever cheese combo you like)
- King’s Hawaiian Rolls
- Peanut Butter (or Almond, whatever butter you like)
- Jelly/Jam
- Chips/Pretzels/Snacks
- Brownie Bites (I bought mine – or you can make a brownie mix and cut them into squares)
- Cookies (I bought mine)
- Serving Tray (I used this one. I love it! You can also see all my party faves in my Amazon Storefront)
How to Make Your Comfort Food Platter
These are not new recipes. I’m pretty sure everyone knows how to make a grilled cheese and a PB&J. But, I can offer some suggestions for the prep and making of this comfort food party platter! If you’d rather see a video, check out the TikTok I made below. Otherwise, keep on reading.
Step 1: Prep the Bread
First thing I did was prep all the bread. For the grilled cheese, I bought pre-sliced bread, so no need to cut a baguette. These were the perfect size for bite size sandwiches. So, for the prep on these, simply butter them and then place a piece of shaved parmesan, or a pinch of shredded parm on each slice.
For the PB&J sandwiches, I did them two ways. I toasted some bread on the stove and left some soft because King’s Hawaiian Rolls are so good soft too! To prep them, I did slice them. So I cut each roll into about four slices. They end up looking like tiny slices of bread, which is so fun!
Step 2: On the Stove
I put all the grilled cheese bread slices on the pan on medium heat. While those are heating up and toasting, I started putting my peanut butter and jelly on the Hawaiian rolls. Keep an eye on those grilled cheese bread slices. A couple min after they’ve been heating up, I add the cheese onto half of the slices. That way it can start to melt. As they cook, top the sandwiches with the other slices and flip as needed until a melty cheese, golden brown sandwiches are made! All the while, keep peanut butter and jellying your Hawaiian Rolls.
Step 3: Plating your Comfort Food Party Platter
I used this party platter. It’s super versatile and a great shape for this kind of platter. I plated the sandwiches on either end. I stood them up on their sides, for pretty presentation. On either side of the sandwiches in the little side trays, I put some of my favorite snacks to eat with sandwiches: pretzels, Doritos and Cheetos.
In the middle, I placed the desserts. I bought brownie bites and cookies from the bakery section at the grocery store. You could totally bake your brownies and cookies if that’s your thing, but I’m terrible at baking! So, I bought mine! No shame! This blog is all about creative and easy party planning, so do what works best for you. 🙂
Wrap Up
That’s it! It’s that simple. This comfort food party platter is a crowd favorite and can work for so many of your party themes. You could also recreate this with any kind of sandwich you like, maybe a club, or turkey sandwich, burger slider. Almost anything will work with this setup. If you want some more party ideas, check out EventOTB’s Pinterest Page. Happy partying!
